A former Labour minister has told a public inquiry into the Post Office Horizon computer system scandal that the treatment of sub-postmasters was "shocking".

Stephen Byers, Secretary of State at the Department for Trade and Industry between December 1998 and June 2001, was the first former government minister to give evidence.

More than 700 Post Office branch managers were given criminal convictions for stealing company money.

It has been called the most widespread miscarriage of justice in UK history.

Sub-postmasters were falsely accused of theft and false accounting based on information from the Horizon computer system, which was later found to have flaws.

The BBC reports that dozens of convictions have since been overturned and many sub-postmasters are in line for compensation.

Sincere regrets

Mr Byers said: "I would like to offer my sincere regrets for what has occurred and to say sorry for the hurt suffered by those involved. We must do all we can to ensure this never happens again."

The inquiry also heard there were "significant disagreements" between the Labour Government's departments involved in Horizon's future, which originally included the development of a new benefit payment card for the Department for Social Security.

He was also asked if he had been aware of any of the concerns raised in the procurement and tendering process for the project.

He said there was a protocol where members of a new government weren't able to see documents or papers provided to the previous administration, so this meant he and his fellow ministers weren't able to see any details of the tendering process or any difficulties already experienced with Horizon.

"It was all denied to us...it was a veil we couldn't lift," he said.

Mr Byers suggested that cancelling the contract with Fujitsu, the Japanese firm that developed the Horizon software, would have resulted in huge losses and there was also concern about the effect on foreign investment.

Automation 'vital'

He also said that automation of the Post Office network was seen as vital to its future and that it would have been necessary to develop a similar programme, which could have taken several years and cost even more money.

The government, Mr Byers said, had insisted on live trials of Horizon to ensure the system worked and that procedures had been put in place to make sure ministers were alerted if any problems arose.

Mr Byers said he did not recall any significant concerns about technical issues with Horizon being flagged during the remainder of his time as secretary of state.

In written evidence heard by the inquiry, former Prime Minister Tony Blair said that while he had "very limited recollection" of the events around that time, he did remember some concerns were raised about Horizon's reliability.

"I recall making clear that, if the problems with the project related solely to commercial aspects, then I was content to continue to work to try to find a way forward, but if there were concerns about product reliability then we should not. I recall that I subsequently received the necessary reassurances as to reliability," he wrote.

Mr Blair added: "It is now clear that the Horizon product was seriously flawed, leading to tragic and completely unacceptable consequences, and I have deep sympathy for those affected."

The second phase of the public inquiry, looking at the pilot, design and roll-out of Horizon, will continue until December 2.

FTSE 100

The UK's top share index, the FTSE 100, was up six points at 7,473 shortly after opening this morning, following yesterday's one-point gain.

No FTSE 350 companies are due to report today.

Brent crude futures were 0.35% higher at $85.66 a barrel.

More like this…

View all