Johnston Carmichael’s Mark Stewart, Partner and Sector Head of Energy, Infrastructure and Sustainability, and David Wilson, Aberdeen Office Managing Partner, reflect on the survey’s findings, the challenges facing the North-east’s energy sector and the policy decisions needed to unlock investment, protect jobs and deliver a successful energy transition.

1. Mark Stewart – Johnston Carmichael

Partner and Sector Head of Energy, Infrastructure and Sustainability

The 44th Energy Transition Survey paints a picture of an industry that remains ambitious and resilient, yet challenged by the gap between political ambition and commercial reality.

There are encouraging signs. Expectations for revenue and profitability have improved, businesses continue to identify opportunities in emerging markets, and Scotland retains extraordinary expertise across energy, engineering and infrastructure.

Notwithstanding the challenging policy environment, significant projects are progressing, investment continues to flow into the sector, and businesses across supply chains are demonstrating innovation and determination.

We should recognise and celebrate that progress.

However, the survey also highlights some uncomfortable realities. Confidence in the UK Continental Shelf remains subdued, while international markets continue to offer growth opportunities and businesses increasingly expect a greater proportion of future revenues to come from overseas. Capital is internationally mobile, and investors will always be tempted towards opportunities offering greater certainty and commercially sustainable returns.

That presents a challenge for policymakers. We need a coherent, long-term energy and industrial strategy that transcends political cycles and provides confidence in a pipeline of investable projects.

Equally, we need a coordinated approach to the infrastructure underpinning the transition. Grid capacity and energy networks are crucial, but so too are housing, schools, health, transport links and access to services. Without these, communities will struggle to attract and retain the people needed to deliver projects.

The findings around employment and skills are equally concerning. Scotland has spent decades developing world-class energy capabilities, yet respondents question whether emerging sectors will replace opportunities lost in traditional oil and gas. We cannot afford to lose the very people, businesses and supply chains essential to delivering the transition.

The recently announced £2 billion Energy Wealth Fund is an opportunity to reverse that by connecting North Sea revenues with the next generation of energy investment. Its success should be judged not by the announcement itself, but by its ability to unlock projects, attract private capital and deliver jobs and infrastructure.

One particularly interesting theme emerging from this year’s survey is what I would describe as the sustainability paradox. While 58% of respondents would maintain their sustainability commitments even if regulation were relaxed, the proportion without a formal sustainability programme has increased from 16% to 31%. At the same time, those regarding sustainability as commercially essential have fallen from 22% to just 13%.

This suggests businesses have not necessarily lost their commitment to sustainability, but that implementation is being deprioritised. Against a backdrop of rising costs, squeezed margins and wider economic uncertainty, shorter-term commercial pressures may increasingly be crowding out longer-term investment.

The irony is that sustainability should be part of the solution rather than a casualty of those pressures. Greater energy efficiency, resource productivity, reduced operating costs and improved resilience can contribute directly to commercial performance. Our challenge is to reconnect sustainability with tangible business value, moving it beyond a compliance obligation.

The survey emphasises that energy security, affordability, economic growth and decarbonisation must be complementary objectives rather than competing priorities. Delivering them calls for joined-up planning and partnerships between public and private capital.

Ultimately, I remain optimistic about the opportunities ahead. It’s clear to me that Scotland and the wider UK possess the expertise, infrastructure, entrepreneurial talent and natural resources to play a leading role in the global energy transition.

Ambition alone will not deliver the transition. Investment, infrastructure and long-term policy certainty will.

2. David Wilson – Johnston Carmichael

Aberdeen Office Managing Partner

The latest AGCC Energy Transition Survey presents a stark message: the North-east of Scotland has the expertise, businesses and ambition to remain at the heart of the global energy industry, but the UK is at risk of undermining that position through policy uncertainty and a failure to translate ambition into investment.

The numbers speak for themselves. The 44th Energy Transition Survey records a confidence balance for the UK Continental Shelf (UKCS) of minus 48 over the next year and minus 57 over five years. For international markets, the equivalent figures are plus 54 and plus 56. Businesses expect the UK share of their revenues to fall from 56% to 45%. This is not simply a question of sentiment. These numbers reflect where companies believe they can secure work, deploy capital and build their future.

For Aberdeen and the North-east region, the consequences extend far beyond oil and gas producers. Our engineering, manufacturing, technology, professional services and wider supply chains have been built on decades of energy expertise. Losing investment and activity in the UKCS risks eroding that industrial base, taking skilled people and capability elsewhere, and weakening the very foundations on which successful diversification depends.

The transition must clearly be delivered rather than merely promised. There is no question that Scotland must develop new energy industries, but aspirations for offshore wind, hydrogen, carbon capture and other technologies cannot replace established activity until projects are consented, financed, constructed and generating sustainable commercial returns. The danger is that traditional activity declines faster than new opportunities can scale.

Recent developments demonstrate that a more pragmatic approach is possible. The approval of the Jackdaw gas field is a welcome recognition that domestic production, energy security, employment and the transition to lower-carbon energy must be considered together. Other projects are still progressing, including recent investment by Sumitomo Electric at the Port of Nigg, for example.

These are forward steps, but they do not resolve the wider uncertainty facing the basin.

The outstanding decisions on Rosebank and the future fiscal and licensing framework remain critically important.

The latest Budget is a missed opportunity and has done very little to reassure the industry or limit any challenges. The Energy Profit Levy has been retained, with its preferred replacement – The UK Oil and Gas Revenue Levy - arriving in 2030, creating continued uncertainty for operators and, importantly, the supply chain.

The argument remains for a credible, balanced approach that recognises continuing domestic demand for oil and gas, the comparative emissions and economic consequences of imports, and the value of retaining industrial capability here in the UK.

The survey should be read as a warning to policymakers. Businesses are making choices today about investment, recruitment and where to pursue future growth. Once capital, people and supply-chain capability have moved elsewhere, rebuilding them will be difficult, expensive and time-consuming.

The North-east has repeatedly demonstrated its ability to adapt and lead. Now it lacks a policy environment that gives businesses the confidence to invest, supports a competitive domestic energy industry and ensures that the transition creates tangible economic opportunities.

The UK cannot afford a managed decline in existing capability while waiting for an uncertain replacement. The opportunity remains significant but we need ambitious action now, not tomorrow, that secures investment, protects skills and delivers new industries at pace.

More like this…

View all